Paignton 2003
Judge: Mrs B Metcalfe
Utility group critique
I was
most appreciative of Paignton Ch. Show Committee for inviting me to
judge the Utility Group. I short listed the Dalmatian, Japanese
Shiba Inu, Keeshond, Min Schnauzer, Std.Poodle, Min Poodle, Shar
Pei, Shih Tzu, and Tibetan Terrier for further consideration. I
pulled out the Keeshond, Std. Poodle, Shih Tzu, and the Tibetan
Terrier for the placings.
G4 The Shih Tzu Frank’s Ch.
Hashana’s Flash Point. Everything correct on examination, a true
head and expression, solid, true movement, would have liked a little
more furnishing for a higher placing.
Clare Coxall
Dog CC : Mrs D STIRZAKER Harropine the Devonian at Mylurose
Res Dog CC : Mrs P M MAULE Ch Daltricia Menelaus JW
Bitch CC, BOB & Gp4: Mrs J FRANKS Ch Hashanah Flash Point
Res Bitch CC : Miss J SALT Harropine American Beauty at Metadale
Best Puppy : Mrs J FRANKS Hashanah Take Me I'm Yours
I was extremely pleased with all my prize winners and in both challenges the exhibits went away showing evenly spaced legs and full pads. I encountered two problems which I penalised heavily. Front construction I found really worrying, in some cases it was difficult to fit three fingers between the legs, reminding me of the Victorian pictures of Queen Anne fronted Dashchunds with many coming towards me centring to the middle and one bitch actually crossing her front legs. The other fault I found creeping in was lack of bone and substance.
MPD.
(7).
1. Ace’s, Bar of Gold with Matsonic. Well constructed gold and
white. Broad masculine head, nice dark eye. Excellent width
throughout. Seemed to be enjoying his day.
2. Flack and Hannah’s, Mifcahs Fast and Furious. Another promising gold and white
youngster. Nice broad jaw and well muscled neck.
3. Phillip’s, Kinafarer Triggered Legacy.
Res: Lord's Huxlor Blazing All Guns
VHC: Vanitonia Against All Odds
PD.
(3).
1. Bolt’s, Kucheng Perfect Timing. Grey brindle and white.
Pleasing expression, well constructed giving sound free flowing
movement. BPD.
2. Davies’s, Navross Spirit in the Sky. Gold brindle
and white. Strong masculine head. Pleasing profile. Moved freely
with style.
3. Hillard’s, Otraharp the Illusionist.
JD.
(6,1).
1. Barker and Nault’s, Wynele Realisation. Gold brindle and
white just out of puppy. Pleasing expression and outline. Good neck
and balanced by excellent tail carriage. Sound free flowing movement
in excellent coat and condition. A youngster whose career I will
watch with interest.
2. Culverhouse’s, Lykaths Legolas. Another very
promising youngster. Attractive black and white. Well constructed,
ultra sound but not the style of movement of the winner.
3. Beer’s, Harropine Gunther.
Res: Mifcahs Just For William
VHC: Maitreya's Crackerjack
ND.
(3).
1. Mead’s, Harropine Maybe This Time for Chaucer. Black masked
gold. Strong masculine head, big dark eye. Well arched neck. Good
width throughout. Moved soundly with style.
2. Hillard’s, Otraharp
the Illusionist. Gold and white good neck and outline. Handled much
better in this class under the improved conditions.
3. Flack and
Hannah’s, Mifcahs Just for William.
PGD.
(6).
1. Diffey’s, Daltricia Pygmalion at Marhilway. Red brindle and
white. Well constructed, excellent neck and tail carriage. Scored in
style and freedom of movement.
2. Ruffer’s, Ethelsmead Durty Harry.
Black and white. Good head and eye. Pleasing masculine expression.
Moved with style.
3. Castle’s, Castillians Heir of Magic.
Res: Seadog His Magic Moment
VHC: Mylurose Touchin Wood For Morhenjo
LD.
(7,2).
1. Stirzaker’s, Harropine the Devonian at Mylurose. Grey and
white, broad head, nice dark eye. Pleasing masculine expression,
well muscled neck with correct balanced tail carriage. Good width
throughout. In excellent coat and condition. Excellent angulation at
both ends allowing him to move freely with style and drive. CC.
2.
Quick’s, Minfaa Rhinestone Cowboy. Gold and white in good coat.
Excellent profile and free flowing stylish movement.
3. Flack and
Hannah’s, Tangse Don’t Worry be Happy with Mifcah.
Res: Otraharp Moving Experience
VHC: Navross Steel Dawn
OD.
(3).
1. Maule’s, Ch. Daltricia Menelaus JW. Impressive gold and
white masculine dog. Plenty of width throughout. In excellent coat
and condition. Presented and handled to perfection. Moved soundly
with drive. RCC.
2. Frank’s, Ch. Hashanah Hot Shot. Attractive red
and white. Well constructed. Excellent profile and balance. In
excellent coat and condition. Handled to advantage.
3. Goodwins’,
Chelhama Aquarius.
MPB.
(11,1). A super class with several promising babies unplaced.
1.
Goodwin’s, Cabbala Happiness Is. A red and white who caught my eye
with her overall style and ring presence. Feminine, beautifully
constricted with plenty of width and substance. A truly promising
youngster whose career I will watch with interest.
2. Flack and
Hannah’s, Mifcahs Move Over Dad. Gold and white, good head, nice
dark eye. In excellent coat and condition. Moved soundly with style
and balance.
3. Stirzaker’s, Mylurose Scarlet Ribbons.
Res: Paliden Make a Wish at Keytor
VHC: Maitreya Superstition
PB.
(6).
1. Frank’s, Hashanah Take me I’m Yours. Another very pleasing
stylish red and white. Feminine yet sturdy. Good head, neck and
tail. Well constructed. Moved freely with style and drive. Won BP
with her front extension when moving.
2. Davies’s, Navross Miss
Rosie Ribbons. Pleasing well constructed gold and white. Good head,
eye and width. Moved freely with style. Just needs to settle down
and get her act together.
3. Russell and Evans’, Matsuba
Scandalizer.
Res: Otraharp Minnyhaha
VHC: Kucheng This Time Baby
JB.
(6,1). A very difficult decision both first and second were excellent
in profile but I would have liked a little more width throughout.
1.
Goodwin’s, Cabbala Ready Steady Glow. Well constructed red and
white. Excellent head and tailset. I would have liked a little more
animation on the day. 2. Hitt’s, Cedarhyth Classic Design. Stricking
black and white. In excellent coat and condition. 3. Goodwin’s,
Chelhama Secret Affair.
Res: Harropine Dye Another Day of Middletune
VHC: Vanitonia Country Girl
NB.
(2).
1. Hillard’s, Otraharp Minnyhaha. Sweet feminine gold and
white. Pleasing outline. Moved with style.
2. Diffey’s, Marhilway
Nite Star. Good head and eye. Plenty of width. Sound but not steady
mover. Coat needs to settle.
PGB.
(8,4).
1. Merrett’s, Venustus Fantasia. Grey and white. Nice type.
Moved soundly with style. Scored in width and extension of front
movement.
2. Goodwin’s, Kucheng Klassic Capers at Cabbala. Grey and
white. Beautiful head, eye and expression. Handled and presented to
perfection.
3. Rutter’s, Ethelsmead Wenarry Met Dazy.
Res: Balise Geisha Girl
LB.
(12,1).
1. Johnson’s, Paliden Walk That Walk at Keytor. Well
constructed. Ultra sound gold and white. Good head, nice dark eye.
2. Salt’s, Harropine Minfaa Chatilly Lace. Gold and white sweet
feminine expression. Well presented in excellent coat and condition.
Sound construction. Moved easily with style and drive.
3. Merrett’s,
Venustus Bette Davis Eyes.
Res: Berylendan's Madam Butterfly
VHC: Glentoth Cofi 'n' Cream With Matsonic
OB.
(7).
1. Frank’s, Hashanah Flash Point. Sweet feminine red and white.
Well constructed, good head, eye and expression. Well muscled neck,
balanced, correct tail carriage. Handled and presented to
perfection. Moved freely with style and drive. CC and BOB. She went
even better in the big ring to get G4.
2. Salt’s, Harropine America
Beauty at Metadale. Black and white in excellent coat and condition.
Good head, neck and eye. Well constructed with plenty of width and
substance. Flowed effortlessly round the ring. RCC.
3. Russel and
Evans’, Ym Toosexy from Audreys Paradis.
Res: Minfaa Dancing Queen
VHC: Jardhu Jezebel of Balise
Barbara Metcalfe